7/23/2019 HOTRREA CSJ Despre Huliganism

1/4

HOTRREA PLENULUI CURII SUPREME DE JUSTIIE A REPUBLICII MOLDOVA Cuprivire la pracica !u"iciar# $% cau&ele pe%ale "e'pre (uli)a%i'* %r+, "i% -.+/0+1//0Bulei%ul Cur2ii Supre*e "e Ju'i2ie a Repu3licii M4l"4va5 1//65 %r+-5 pa)+-- 7 7 7 %'c4pul aplic#rii c4rece 8i u%i94r*e a le)i'la2iei care vi&ea e:a*i%area cau&el4r"e'pre (uli)a%i'*5 $% c4%94r*iae cu li+ e; ar+1 8i li+ c; ar+-0 "i% Le)ea cu privirela Curea Supre*# "e Ju'i2ie5 Ple%ul a"4p# pre&e%a (4#r$re cu caracer

e:plicaiv< -+ Av$%" $% ve"ere 9apul c# (uli)a%i'*ul c4%'iuie 4 i%9rac2iu%er#'p$%"i# 8i pericul4a'#5 care ae%ea la 4r"i%ea pu3lic#5 li%i8ea ce#2e%il4r 8icare5 "e'e4ri5 c4%"uce la '#v$r8irea al4r i%9rac2iu%i *ul *ai )rave5 i%'a%2ele

!u"ec#4re8i v4r a'i)ura '4lu2i4%area 4peraiv# a cau&el4r "i% acea'# cae)4rie5re'pec$%" cu 'rice2e preve"erile le)ii+ 1+ I%9rac2iu%ea "e (uli)a%i'*5 prev#&u# laar+1=6 CP5 repre&i%# ac2iu%ile i%e%2i4%ae care $%calc# )r4'4la% 4r"i%ea pu3lic# 8ie:pri*# 4 v#"i# lip'# "e re'pec 9a2# "e '4cieae5 *a%i9e'ae pri% 4ricare "i%ur*#4arele a'pece< a; ac2iu%i $%'42ie "e aplicarea vi4le%2ei a'upra per'4a%el4r>3; ac2iu%i $%'42ie "e a*e%i%2area cu aplicarea vi4le%2ei a'upra per'4a%el4r> c;ac2iu%i $%'42ie "e 4pu%erea "e re&i'e%2# repre&e%a%2il4r au4ri#2il4r 'au al4rper'4a%e care cur*# acele (uli)a%ice> "; ac2iu%i care5 pri% c4%2i%uul l4r5 'e

"e4'e3e'c pri% ci%i'* 'au 43r#&%icie "e4'e3i#+ Reie8i%" "i% "i'p4&i2iile le)iipe%ale5 i%'a%2ele !u"ec#4re8i v4r "i'i%)e rei 94r*e "e (uli)a%i'*5 pa'i3ile "er#'pu%"ere pe%al#5 8i a%u*e < -+ (uli)a%i'* 'i*plu prev#&u "e ar+1=6 ali%+ ?-; CP>1+ (uli)a%i'* cali@ca prev#&u "e ar+1=6 ali%+?1; CP> + (uli)a%i'* a)ravaprev#&u "e ar+1=6 ali%+ ?; CP+ + Or"i%e pu3lic# $%'ea*%# 4 4aliae "e rela2ii'4ciale ce a'i)ur# 4 a*3ia%2# li%i8i# "e c4%vie2uire $% '4cieae5 "e i%vi4la3iliae aper'4a%ei 8i a i%e)ri#2ii pari*4%iului5 precu* 8i aciviaea %4r*al# a i%'iu2iil4r"e 'a 8i pu3lice+ %c#lcare )r4'4la%# a 4r"i%ii pu3lice ce e:pri*# 4 v#"i# lip'# "ere'pec 'e c4%'i"er# '#v$r8irea u%4r ac2iu%i i%e%2i4%ae ce ae%ea la re)ulile'4ciale 8i *4rale "e c4%vie2uire5 care 'u% $%c#lcae $%ru% *4" )r4'4la% 8i"e*4%'raiv "e c#re vi4la4rul 4r"i%ii pu3lice pri% %ecuvii%2#5 %e43r#&are5

c4*p4rare 3a!4c4ri4are cu ce#2e%ii5 pri% $%!4'ire a 4%4arei 8i "e*%i#2iiper'4a%ei5 $%c#lcare $%"elu%)a# 8i i%'i'e%# a 4r"i%ii pu3lice5 "#r%icire aacivi#2il4r "e *a'#5 'u'pe%"are e*p4rar# a acivi#2ii %4r*ale a $%repri%"eril4r5i%'iu2iil4r5 4r)a%i&a2iil4r5 ra%'p4rului 438e'c ec+ Pri% e:pri*area u%ei v#"ielip'e "e re'pec 9a2# "e '4cieae 'e au $% ve"ere ac2iu%ile evi"e%e ce ai%)i%ere'ele le)ii*e ale u%ui )rup 4ri c(iar ale u%ei per'4a%e care 'e a# la l4culi%9rac2iu%ii ?pr49erarea "e e:pre'ii i%"ece%e5 a34r"area u%ei 2i%ue lip'ie "epu"4are5 e9ecuarea "e )e'uri 43'ce%e ec+; Huli)a%i'*ul $%'42i "e aplicareavi4le%2ei a'upra per'4a%el4r 'au "e a*e%i%2area cu aplicarea u%ei a'e*e%eavi4le%e c4%'iuie a$ vi4le%2a p'i(ic#5 c$ 8i cea @&ic#5 ce 'e p4ae *a%i9e'a pri%cau&area u%4r pre!u"icii '#%##2ii5 care p4 'urve%i $% ur*a '#v$r8irii u%4r ac2iu%i cu

caracer vi4le%5 pr4"u'e pri% aplicarea "e l4viuri5 pri% i*43ili&area5 $*3r$%cirea5pu%erea u%ei pie"ici vici*ei5 ur*ae "e v##*area i%e)ri#2ii c4rp4rale 'au "ele&iu%i c4rp4rale5 'au 9#r# cau&area pre!u"iciului '#%##2ii+ A*e%i%2area pre'upu%e4rice ac pri% care 'e reali&ea 4 c4%'r$%)ere *4ral#5 "e %aur# '# i%'ue e*erecu privire la aplicarea vi4le%2ei @&ice5 ur*a# "e pr4v4carea u%4r le&iu%i "e)raviae "i9eri#5 i%clu'iv p$%# la cau&area *4r2ii+ Pri% 4pu%ere "e re&i'e%#repre&e%a%2il4r au4ri#2il4r 'au al4r per'4a%e care cur*# acele (uli)a%ice 'e

$%2ele)e '#v$r8irea u%4r ac2iu%i @&ice acive "e 4pu%ere "e re&i'e%2#5 care 'ereali&ea $% pr4ce'ul c4*ierii acel4r "e (uli)a%i'*+ I)%4rarea ceri%2el4rper'4a%el4r i%"icae "e a $%cea aciviaea (uli)a%ic# %u c4%'iuie 4pu%ere "ere&i'e%2#+ Nu*ai i%erve%2ia @&ic#5 94l4'irea 94r2ei pe%ru cur*area ac2iu%il4r @&ice

'e c4%'i"er# "rep 4pu%ere "e re&i'e%2#+ Pri% (uli)a%i'* $%'42i "e u% ci%i'*"e4'e3i 'e are $% ve"ere $%c#lcarea i%'i'e%# 8i "e*4%'raiv# a re)ulil4r *4rale5*a%i9e'a# pri% "i'pre2uire 8i 3a!4cur# 9a2# "e 34l%avi5 "e per'4a%ele $% eae5

7/23/2019 HOTRREA CSJ Despre Huliganism

2/4

aae $% 'are "e %epui%2#5 pri% purare %eru8i%a# $% pre&e%2a al4r per'4a%e5re&i%" i%"i)%area ace'4ra5 ec+ Su3 43r#&%icie "e4'e3i# 'e $%2ele) ac2iu%ile "e

$%c#lcare )r4'4la%# a 4r"i%ii pu3lice $%'42ie "e ace "e vi4le%2# a'upra per'4a%ei5"e "i'ru)ere 8i "e)ra"are a 3u%uril4r pr4priearului+ Ac2iu%ile "e (uli)a%i'* '$%4rie%ae5 "e re)ul#5 'pre pu3lic5 'pre reac2ia pu3licului5 i*plic$%" !i)%irea "e*%i#2iipu3lice 8i $%c#lcarea )r4'4la%# a 4r"i%ii pu3lice+ Ac2iu%ile "e (uli)a%i'*5 $% 'pa2iu 8i

i*p5 'e p4 $%9#pui 8i $% l4curi %ep4pulae 'au %4apea5 "ar cu $%c#lcarea 4r"i%iipu3lice+ La 9el5 'e p4 c4*ie 8i ac2iu%i "e (uli)a%i'* (a3iual< $% apara*e%ec4*u%ale5 $% 4)r#&i5 pe 'car# ec+ % aare 'iua2ie5 9#pui4rul p4ar# r#'pu%"ere"ac# $8i "#"ea 'ea*a 8i c4%8ie%i&a c# $%calc# )r4'4la% 4r"i%ea pu3lic#+ ,+Huli)a%i'* a)rava $%'ea*%# '#v$r8irea ac2iu%il4r prev#&ue la ali%+?-; ar+1=6 CP $%circu*'a%2e a)rava%e5 cu aplicarea 'au $%cercarea aplic#rii ar*ei "e 94c5 acu2iel4r5 34:el4r 'au a al4r ar*e al3e5 precu* 8i a 43iecel4r 'pecial a"apaepe%ru v##*area i%e)ri#2ii c4rp4rale 'au a '#%##2ii ?ar+1=6 ali%+ ?; CP;+Huli)a%i'*ul 'i*plu ?ar+1=6 ali%+ ?-; CP; e'e ari3ui "e c#re le)iui4r la cae)4riau%ei i%9rac2iu%i *ai pu2i% )rave ?ar+-0 ali%+?; CP;5 iar cel cali@ca 8i cel a)rava?ar+1=6 ali%+?1;5?; CP; 'u% c4%'i"erae i%9rac2iu%i )rave+ + La 'a3ilirea ar*ei "e

94c 'au ar*ei al3e i%'a%2ele "e !u"eca# 'e v4r c4%"uce "e e:plica2iile "i%H4#r$rea Ple%ului Cur2ii Supre*e "e Ju'i2ie %r+- "i% . %4ie*3rie -..= Cu privirela pracica !u"iciar# $% cau&ele pe%ale "e'pre purarea ?p4rul;5 p#'rarea?"e2i%erea;5 ra%'p4rarea5 9a3ricarea5 c4*erciali&area ile)al#5 'u'ra)erea ar*el4r"e 94c5 a *u%i2iil4r 'au a 'u3'a%2el4r e:pl4&ive5 p#'rarea %e)li!e%# a ar*el4r "e94c 8i a *u%i2iil4rF+ Su3 i%ci"e%2a ali%+?; ar+1=6 CP ca"e 4rice ar*# al3# care va @recu%4'cu# ca aare $% rap4rul e:perului+ O3iece 'pecial a"apae pe%ruv##*area i%e)ri#2ii c4rp4rale ur*ea a @ c4%'i"erae cele care au 94' a"apae"e 9#pui4r "i% i*p 'au $% *4*e%ul '#v$r8irii ac2iu%il4r (uli)a%ice5 precu* 8i43iecele care5 "e8i %au 94' 'upu'e prelucr#rii5 au 94' 'pecial pre)#ie "e c#re9#pui4r 8i 'e aau la el cu acela8i 'c4p+ 0+ Huli)a%i'*ul 'e c4%'i"er# '#v$r8i

repea ?li+a; ali%+?1; ar+1=6 CP; $% ca&ul c4*ierii a "4u# 'au *ai *ul4r i%9rac2iu%i"e (uli)a%i'* cu c4%"i2ia c# per'4a%a %u a 94' c4%"a*%a# pe%ru vreu%a "i% ele8i %u a e:pira er*e%ul "e pre'crip2ie+ Cali@carea re3uie 9#cu# %u*ai c4%94r*re)ulil4r c4%cur'ului "e i%9rac2iu%i5 9#r# i%v4carea preve"erii "e la li+a; ali%+?1;ar+1=6 CP5 $% ur*#4arele ca&uri< -; (uli)a%i'*ul e'e ur*a "e 4 i%9rac2iu%e4*4)e%# prev#&u# "e u% al ali%ea al ar+1=6 CP> 1; (uli)a%i'*ul c4%'u*a e'eur*a "e e%aiv# "e (uli)a%i'* 'au pre)#ire "e (uli)a%i'* 4ri vicever'a> ; $%pri*ul ca& per'4a%a e'e au4r al (uli)a%i'*ului5 $% al "4ilea ca& ea e'e4r)a%i&a4r5 i%'i)a4r 'au c4*plice la (uli)a%i'* 4ri vicever'a+ 6+ % ca&ul $% care 4per'4a%# a '#v$r8i $% peri4a"e "i9erie "4u# 'au *ai *ule i%9rac2iu%i5 pe%ru carere'p4%'a3iliaea e'e prev#&u# "e "i9erie ali%eae ale aric4lului 1=6 CP5 9apele

'#v$r8ie "e 9#pui4r 'e v4r c4%'i"era5 la 9el5 (uli)a%i'* repea+ $%'#5 $% a'e*e%eaca&uri5 cali@carea "e@%iiv# 'e va e9ecua $% 3a&a ali%eaului ce preve"e 4 pe"eap'#*ai )rav#5 i%"ic$%"u'e 4ae 'e*%ele c4%'iuive ale (uli)a%i'*ului+ =+Huli)a%i'*ul 'e c4%'i"er# '#v$r8i "e "4u# 'au *ai *ule per'4a%e ?li+3; ali%+?1;ar+1=6 CP; au%ci c$%"< a; e '#v$r8i "e "4i 'au *ai *ul2i c4au4ri> 3; e '#v$r8i "ec#re 4 per'4a%# care $%ru%e8e 'e*%ele 'u3iecului i%9rac2iu%ii $% c4*u% cu 4per'4a%# care %u $%ru%e8e ace'e 'e*%e+ Lip'a 'au pre&e%2a $%2ele)erii preala3ile"i%re per'4a%ele care '#v$r8e'c (uli)a%i'*ul 'e ia $% c4%'i"era2ie lai%"ivi"uali&area pe"ep'ei+ .+ I%'a%2ele !u"ec#4re8i ur*ea '# "eli*ie&e(uli)a%i'*ul "e ale i%9rac2iu%i $% "epe%"e%2# "e 'e%'ul 8i 4rie%area i%e%2iei9#pui4rului5 "e *4ivele5 'c4purile 8i circu*'a%2ele ac2iu%il4r '#v$r8ie "e el+

I%'ulele5 l4viurile5 cau&area v##*#ril4r c4rp4rale u84are5 *e"ii5 )rave 8i aleac2iu%i "e ace' 9el5 '#v$r8ie $% 9a*ilie5 apara*e%5 $% privi%2a ru"el4r5 cu%4'cu2il4r8i pr4v4cae "e rela2iile per'4%ale 4'ile ec+5 v4r @ cali@cae $% 3a&a aric4lel4r

7/23/2019 HOTRREA CSJ Despre Huliganism

3/4

C4"ului pe%al ce prev#" r#'pu%"erea pe%ru i%9rac2iu%ile $*p4riva vie2ii 8i '#%##2iiper'4a%ei+ %'#5 $% ca&urile $% care a'e*e%ea ac2iu%i au 94' $%'42ie "e 4 $%c#lcare)r4'4la%# evi"e%# a 4r"i%ii pu3lice "e c#re 9#pui4r 8i au e:pri*a 4 v#"i# lip'#"e re'pec 9a2# "e '4cieae5 ace'e ac2iu%i ur*ea a @ cali@cae "rep (uli)a%i'*+-/+ I%'a%2ele !u"ec#4re8i v4r 2i%e 'ea*a c#< -; per'4a%a care a c4%ri3ui $%caliae "e au4r ?4r)a%i&a4r5 i%'i)a4r5 c4*plice; la '#v$r8irea acel4r (uli)a%ice

va pura r#'pu%"ere c4%94r* ar+,1 8i 1=6 CP> 1; acele "e (uli)a%i'* $%'42ie "e4pu%erea "e re&i'e%2# c4la34ra4ril4r5 repre&e%a%2il4r au4ri#2il4r 'au al4rper'4a%e care cur*# acele (uli)a%ice5 i%clu'iv cele $%'42ie "e vi4le%2# 'au "ea*e%i%2area aplic#rii ei $% privi%2a per'4a%el4r i%"icae5 'u% cupri%'e c4*ple $%ali%+ ?-; ar+1=6 8i %u %ece'i# 4 cali@care 'upli*e%ar# c4%94r* al4r aric4le "i%C4"ul pe%al> ; re&i'e%2a 4pu'# "up# $%cearea acel4r (uli)a%ice5 $% 'pecial $%le)#ur# cu re2i%erea uleri4ar# a vi%4vaului5 %u va @ e:a*i%a# ca 4 circu*'a%2#care cali@c# (uli)a%i'*ul5 ea ur*ea a @ cali@ca# $% c4%cur' cu (uli)a%i'*ul> ,;"ac# ac2iu%ile "e (uli)a%i'* au 94' $%'42ie "e $%c#lcarea re)ulil4r "e 'ecuriae acircula2iei 8i "e e:pl4aare a ra%'p4rului5 ace'e ac2iu%i ur*ea a @ cali@cae pri%c4%cur' "e i%9rac2iu%i5 prev#&ue "e ar+105 10,5 10=5 10.5 16/ 'au 16- 8i 1=6 CP>

; 4*4rul i%e%2i4%a '#v$r8i $% pr4ce'ul acului (uli)a%ic ur*ea a @ cali@ca%u*ai $% 3a&a ar+-, ali%+?1; li+c; CP> 0; (uli)a%i'*ul $%'42i "e v##*areac4rp4ral# )rav# a vici*ei ur*ea a @ cali@ca $% 3a&a ar+-- ali%+?1; li+(; CP> 6;(uli)a%i'*ul $%'42i "e v##*area c4rp4ral# *e"ie a vici*ei ur*ea a @ cali@cap4rivi ali%+?1; li+i; ar+-1 CP> =; ac2iu%ile (uli)a%ice '#v$r8ie "e "4u# 'au *ai*ule per'4a%e cu ur*#rile prev#&ue la ar+-- 8i -1 CP 'e $%ca"rea %u*ai $%3a&a ar+-- ali%+ ?1; li+ ";5 (; 8i5 re'peciv5 ar+-1 ali%+?1; li+e; 8i i; CP> .; $%'u8irea3u%uril4r 'r#i%e "i% i%e%2ii (uli)a%ice5 9#r# 'c4pul "e a le acapara5 va @ cali@ca#ca (uli)a%i'*5 "ar %u ca 9ur5 $l(#rie 'au !a9> -/; ac2iu%ile 9#pui4rului5 "e8i'#v$r8ie "i% *4ive "e 'erviciu 'au per'4%ale5 "ar $%'42ie "e $%c#lc#ri )r4'4la%e ale4r"i%ii pu3lice 8i care e:pri*# 4 v#"i# lip'# "e re'pec 9a2# "e '4cieae5 ur*ea a

@ cali@cae ca (uli)a%i'*> --; (uli)a%i'*ul '#v$r8i cu aplicarea 'au $%cercarea "eaplicare a ar*el4r "e 94c ?cu e:cep2ia ar*ei "e v$%#4are cu 2eava li'#;5 "e2i%ue9#r# au4ri&a2ia c4re'pu%are "e p#'rare a ar*ei5 ur*ea a @ cali@ca c4%94r*ali%+?; ar+1=6 8i ar+1./ CP> -1; "ac# $% re&ulaul (uli)a%i'*ului au 94' cau&ae"au%e $% pr4p4r2ii *ari 'au ale ur*#ri )rave5 cali@carea 'e 9ace pri% c4%cur' "ei%9rac2iu%i< c4%94r* ar+1=6 8i -.6 CP> -; (uli)a%i'*ul $%'42i "e p#ru%"erea 'aur#*$%erea ile)al# $% "4*iciliul 'au $% re8e"i%2a u%ei per'4a%e 9#r# c4%'i*2#*$%ulace'eia5 4ri "e re9u&ul "e a le p#r#'i la cererea ei5 'au "e perc(e&i2iile 8i cerce#rileile)ale re3uie cali@ca c4%94r* ar+1=6 8i -6. CP> -,; (uli)a%i'*ul $%'42i "ea*e%i%2area cu 4*4r 4ri cu v##*area )rav# a i%e)ri#2ii c4rp4rale 'au a '#%##2ii%u %ece'i# cali@carea pri% c4%cur' cu ar+- CP+ --+ Aplicarea 'au i%e%2ia "e a

aplica ar*a "e 94c5 "i9erie cu2ie5 34:e 'au "i9erie ar*e al3e5 precu* 8i ale43iece5 i%clu'iv cele 'pecial a"apae pe%ru v##*area i%e)ri#2ii c4rp4rale la'#v$r8irea acel4r "e (uli)a%i'*5 c4%'iuie e*ei pe%ru cali@carea i%9rac2iu%ii $%3a&a ali%+?; ar+1=6 CP %u %u*ai $% acele ca&uri $% care vi%4vaul cu a!u4rul l4rcau&ea 'au i%e%2i4%ea '# cau&e&e v##*#ri c4rp4rale5 "ar 8i au%ci c$%"uili&area 43iecel4r *e%2i4%ae $% pr4ce'ul acel4r (uli)a%ice creea u% peric4lreal pe%ru via2a 8i '#%#aea ce#2e%il4r+ -1+ Dac#5 $% i*pul '#v$r8irii(uli)a%i'*ului5 u%ul "i%re paricipa%2i aplic# 'au $%cearc# '# aplice ar*a "e 94c5cu2iele5 34:ele 'au ale ar*e al3e5 precu* 8i 43iecele 'pecial a"apae pe%ruv##*area i%e)ri#2ii c4rp4rale 'au a '#%##2ii5 9#r# 8irea cel4rlal2i paricipa%2i5au%ci r#'pu%"erea c4%94r* ali%+?; ar+1=6 CP 4 p4ar# %u*ai per'4a%a care a

c4*i' e:ce'ul "e au4r+ -+ I%'a%2ele !u"ec#4re8i v4r e:a*i%a *i%u2i4'circu*'a%2ele le)ae "e aplicarea 'au $%cercarea "e a aplica ar*ele 8i ale 43iecela '#v$r8irea acel4r (uli)a%ice5 lu$%" $% c4%'i"era2ie c# $% ac2iu%ile 9#pui4rului $%

7/23/2019 HOTRREA CSJ Despre Huliganism

4/4

a%u*ie ca&uri p4 e:i'a i%"icii u%ei i%9rac2iu%i *ul *ai )rave "ec$ (uli)a%i'*ul5"e e:e*plu5 e%aiv# "e 4*4r5 v##*area )rav# a i%e)ri#2ii c4rp4rale 'au al2ii%"ici cali@caivi5 care cer 4 $%ca"rare 'pecial#+ -,+ I%'a%2ele "e !u"eca# v4r 2i%e'ea*a c# ac2iu%ile i%e%2i4%ae care $%calc# )r4'4la% 4r"i%ea pu3lic# 8i e:pri*# 4v#"i# lip'# "e re'pec 9a2# "e '4cieae %u p4 '# 94r*e&e "e 'i%e '##4rc4*p4%e%2a i%9rac2iu%ii "e (uli)a%i'*+ Ace'e ac2iu%i pri%cipale re3uie '# @e

$%'42ie 43li)a4riu "e 4ricare "i% ac2iu%ile a"iace%e *e%2i4%ae $% "i'p4&i2ia ali%+?-; ar+1=6 CP< aplicarea vi4le%2ei a'upra per'4a%el4r 'au a*e%i%2area cu aplicareau%ei a'e*e%ea vi4le%2e5 4pu%erea "e re&i'e%2# repre&e%a%2il4r au4ri#2il4r 'aual4r per'4a%e care cur*# acele (uli)a%ice5 precu* 8i ac2iu%ile care5 pri%c4%2i%uul l4r5 'e "e4'e3e'c pri% ci%i'* 'au 43r#&%icie "e4'e3i#+ Dac# ac2iu%ile ceul3ur# 4r"i%ea pu3lic# 8i li%i8ea ce#2e%il4r ?"e e:e*plu< e:pre'iile i%!uri4a'e $%l4curile pu3lice5 ac4'area !i)%i4are a ce#2e%il4r 8i ale ac2iu%i a'e*#%#4are; %u'$% $%'42ie "e ac2iu%ile a"iace%e5 'peci@cae *ai 'u'5 au%ci cali@carea re3uie9#cu# p4rivi ar+-0, Huli)a%i'*ul %u prea )ravF "i% CCA+ -+ I%'a%2ele

!u"ec#4re8i v4r ara)e 4 "e4'e3i# ae%2ie la !u"ecarea cau&el4r "e (uli)a%i'* cupariciparea *i%4ril4r 8i la 'a3ilirea pe"ep'el4r pe%ru ace8ia+ La e:a*i%area

cau&el4r "e ace' )e% e'e %ece'ar '# 'e cercee&e *i%u2i4'5 'u3 4ae a'pecele5circu*'a%2ele care au le)#ur# cu i%9rac2iu%ea5 cu *4ivele i%9rac2iu%ii5 'pre a 'eevia c4%"a*%area *i%4ril4r pe%ru ac2iu%i cu caracer "e 8re%)#rii c4pil#re8i+ -0+% pracica 'a5 i%'a%2ele !u"ec#4re8i %u re3uie '# a"*i# i%erprearea e:e%'iv#a %42iu%ii "e (uli)a%i'* pa'i3il "e pe"eap'#5 pe%ru ca '# @e e:clu'e ca&urile "era)ere la r#'pu%"ere pe%al# a per'4a%el4r vi%4vae "e u% (uli)a%i'* %u prea )rav'au "e 9ape %e$%'e*%ae5 care ara) r#'pu%"erea a"*i%i'raiv#+ -6+ Lac4%"a*%area pe%ru ac2iu%ile (uli)a%ice $%'42ie "e %i*icirea 'au "eeri4rarea3u%uril4r5 "e v##*area i%e)ri#2ii c4rp4rale a ce#2e%il4r5 care a 94' ur*a# "epier"erea e*p4rar# a capaci#2ii "e *u%c#5 i%'a%2ele !u"ec#4re8i v4r '4lu2i4%a

$% 'e%i%2# c(e'iu%ea cu privire la repararea pa)u3ei *aeriale 8i *4rale cau&ae

"e i%9rac2iu%e %u*ai $% ca&ul $% care v4r @ re'pecae preve"erile ar+1-.110 CPP+-=+ Reie8i%" "i% pri%cipiul i%"ivi"ualirii pe"ep'ei p4rivi preve"eril4r ar+66=CP5 i%'a%2ele !u"ec#4re8i $% 4ae ca&urile v4r aplica 4 pe"eap'# ec(ia3il#5 2i%$%"c4% "e )raviaea i%9rac2iu%ii '#v$r8ie5 "e *4ivul ace'eia5 "e per'4a%a celuivi%4va 8i "e circu*'a%2ele cau&ei care ae%uea 'au a)ravea r#'pu%"erea5 "ei%ue%2a pe"ep'ei aplicae a'upra c4rec#rii 8i ree"uc#rii vi%4vaului5 precu* 8i "ec4%"i2iile "e via2# ale 9a*iliei ace'uia+ -.+ Lu$%" $% c4%'i"era2ie 9apul c# ac2iu%ile(uli)a%ice $% *a!4riaea ca&uril4r '$% '#v$r8ie "i% cau&a 3e2iei5 i%'a%2ele

!u"ec#4re8i ?$% ca&ul "ac# 'e cupri%"e $% $%vi%uire;5 $% i*pul 'a3ilirii pe"ep'eipe%ru per'4a%ele care au '#v$r8i u% ac (uli)a%ic $% 'are "e e3rieae5 ur*ea '#"i'cue c(e'iu%ea "e'pre recu%4a8erea ace'eia ca circu*'a%2# ce a)ravea

pe"eap'a+ La pr4%u%2area 'e%i%2ei5 i%'a%2ele !u"ec#4re8i5 $% 3a&a ar+-/ CP5 v4r"i'cua c(e'iu%ea privi%" aplicarea *#'uril4r "e c4%'r$%)ere cu caracer *e"ical9a2# "e vi%4va2ii5 care ur*ea '# @e raa2i "e alc44li'* 8i %arc4*a%ie+ 1/+ %le)#ur# cu a"4parea pre&e%ei (4#r$ri 'e a3r4)# H4#r$rea Ple%ului Ju"ec#4rieiSupre*e a Repu3licii M4l"4va %r+-1 "i% 1/+-1+-.. FCu privire la pracica !u"iciar#

$% cau&ele "e'pre (uli)a%i'*F+