spete 2008 drepturile omului final

8/9/2019 Spete 2008 Drepturile Omului Final

1/7

UNIVERSITATEA „LUCIAN BLAGA” DIN SIBIU

FACULTATEA DE DREPT „SIMION BARNUTIU”

DISCIPLINA: PROTECTIA EUROPEANA A DREPTURILOR OMULUI

Spete

PROFESOR : Conf. Univ. dr. Biana S!"!#an$G%&an

STUDENT: RUSU 'CRACEA( ANA$MARIA

SPECIALI)ARE: DREPT* AN II* ID*

CENTRUL: SIBIU

+


2/7

SOLUTIONAREA SPETELOR

SPETA NR. +

+.Ar&io"!"! din Conv!n&ia E%ro,!ana a Dr!,&%ri"or O-%"%i in a/a arora

r!"a-an&ii Fana&i0ov 1i Boro/ov i1i ,o& for-%"a 1i ar2%-!n&a !r!r!a adr!1a&a C%r&ii 1%n&:

Ar&io"%" 3'+(: 4ori! ,!r1oana ar! dr!,&%" "a #%d!ar!a in -od !5i&ai" * in

-od ,%"i 1i in&r$%n &!r-!n r!/onai" a a%/!i 1a"! d! a&r! o in1&an&a ind!,!nd!n&a 1i

i-,ar&ia"a *in1&i&%i&a d! "!2! * ar! va 5o&ari fi! a1%,ra ina"arii dr!,&%ri"or 1a"! % ara&!r ivi" *

fi! a1%,ra &!-!inii!i oriar!i a%/a&ii in -a&!ri! ,!na"a indr!,&a&! i-,o&riva 1a”. Do-n%"Fana&i0ov* 6n a"i&a&! d! !di&or 7i r!da&or$7!f a" /iar%"%i onfi1a&* !1&! &ri-i1 6n #%d!a&8 d!

%r2!n98 7i onda-na& ,!na" d! o %r&! d! 1i2%ran98 a 1&a&%"%i* 6nfiin9a&8 ad$5o* ,!n&r% ini&ar! "a

%r8 7i o1&i"i&a&!* "a 6n5i1oar! 7i a-!nd8 ,!na"8. A!!a1i !1&! 1i 1oar&a do-n%"%i Boro/ov* a%&or%"

ar&io"%"%i.

Ar&io"%" '+(: 4ori! ,!r1oana ar! dr!,&%" "a "i!r&a&!a d! 2indir!* d!

on1&iin&a* 1i d! r!"i2i!”. A-ii r!"a-an&i 1%n& !&a&!ni -inori&ari d! r!"i2i! fini1ana iar in

ar&io"%" ,%"ia& 1! -!n&ion!a/a ,!rio"%" in&!2ri1-%"%i r!"i2io1 fini1an .Ar&io"%" +;: 4ori! ,!r1oana ar! dr!,&%" "a "i!ra !an%"%i @;;>* 1! d!r%"!a/8 7i ,ro!d%ri"! d! r!%r1 ini9ia&! 6-,o&riva 5o&8rri"or d! onda-nar!.

C%r&!a d! A,!" r!1,in2! r!%r1%ri"!* iar dr!,&%" "a r!%r1 6n ,rivin9a -81%ri"or d! onfi1ar! !1&!

r!f%/a&.

@


3/7

Ar&io"%" > onf!ra adr%" 2!n!ra" a" dr!,&%"%i d! a 1! adr!1a C%r&ii: „C%r&!a ,oa&! fi

1!1i/a&a ,rin&r$o !r!r! d! a&r! ori! ,!r1oana fi/ia * ori! or2ani/a&i! n!2%v!rna-!n&a"a 1a% d!

ori! 2r%, d! ,ar&i%"ari ar! 1! ,r!&ind vi&i-a a %n!i ina"ari d! a&r! %na din Ina"&!"! Par&i

on&ra&an&! *a dr!,&%ri"or r!%no1%&! in Conv!n&i!”.

Ar&io"%" > ara&a ondi&ii"! d! ad-i1ii"i&a&! a"! !r!rii .

D!oar!! Do-nii Fana&i0ov 1i Boro/ov a% !,%i/a& in &ara ai"! d! r!%r1 'a,!"%" 1i

r!%r1%"( 1i a% r!1,!&a& &!r-!n%" d! 3 "%ni d! "a da&a 5o&ararii in&!rn! d!fini&iv! ,o& d!,%n!

i-,o&riva 1&a&%"%i Vivandia !r!ri "a C%r&!a E%ro,!ana a Dr!,&%ri"or O-%"%i.

C!i"a"&i r!"a-an&i* ,arin&ii "%i A.B. 1i C.D. i1i in&!-!ia/a !r!r!a i-,o&riva 1&a&%"%i

Vivandia a/and%$1! ,! ar&io"%" @'+( ar! afir-a a 4 dr!,&%" "a via&a a" oriar!i ,!r1ona! !1&!

,ro&!#a& d! "!2!”. To&oda&a !r!r!a "or 1! ,oa&! in&!-!ia ,! ,r!v!d!r!a a ro"%" 1&a&!"or !1&! d! a

in&!rv!ni a&iv ,!n&r% 2aran&ar!a dr!,&%"%i "a via&a 1i d! a or2ani/a an5!&! i-,o&riva !"or ar! a%

ad%1 a&in2!r! vi!&ii ,!r1oan!i.

@. S&a&%" Vivandia 1! fa! vinova& d! n!r!1,!&ar!a ar&io"!"or 3'+(* '+(* +;* +>* >* >

din Conv!n&ia E%ro,!ana a Dr!,&%ri"or O-%"%i "a ar! a ad!ra& in a"i&a&! d! -!-r% a"

Con1i"i%"%i E%ro,!i. Prin ina"ar!a a!1&or ar&io"! 1$a ad%1 a&in2!r! dr!,&%ri"or 1i "i!r&a&i"or

do-n%"%i Fana&i0ov 1i Boro/ov a1&f!": a% fo1& #%d!a&i in ,ri-a in1&an&a d! a&r! o %r&! d!

1i2%ran98 a 1&a&%"%i* 6nfiin9a&8 ad$5o in &i-, ! Conv!n&ia ,r!v!d!a a 4ori! ,!r1oana ar! dr!,&%""a #%d!ar!a in -od !5i&ai" * in -od ,%"i 1i in&r$%n &!r-!n r!/onai" a a%/!i 1a"! d! a&r! o

in1&an&a ind!,!nd!n&a 1i i-,ar&ia"a *in1&i&%i&a d! "!2!. D! a1!-!n!a n% "!$a% fo1& r!1,!&a&!

"i!r&a&!a d! 2andir! *d! on1&iin&a 1i d! r!"i2i! ,r!%- 1i dr!,&%" "a "i!ra !


4/7

>. S&a&%" Vivandia 1$ar ,%&!a a,ara 6n ,rivin9a ,"n2!ri"or ,8rin9i"or "%i A.B. 7i a "%i C.D

invoand ,o1ii"i&a&!a ,arin&i"or d! a 1! adr!1a a%&ori&a&i"or "oa"! ,!n&r% a fa! !r!&ari -ai

a-an%n&i&! ,!n&r% a id!n&ifia fa,&%i&or%" 1i ,!n&r% a fi &ra1 "a ra1,%nd!r! ,!na"a.

C!i ra1,%n/a&ori ,!n&r% d!-on1&ra&ia n!a%&ori/a&a* d!!1%" "%i A.B. 1i ranir!a 2rava a "%i

B.C. 1%n& onda-na&i 1i "!$a fo1& onfi1a&a ,%"ia&ia.


5/7

SPETA NR.@

+. C!r!r!a adr!1a&a C%r&ii E%ro,!n! a Dr!,&%ri"or O-%"%i d! a&r! M.D. 1i F.D. 1!

a/!a/a ,! %r-a&oar!"! ar&io"! din Conv!n&i!:

R!f!ri&or "a ar!1&ar!a 1i d!!1%" "%i D.D Conv!n&ia 1&i,%"!a/a a: 4ni-!ni n% ,oa&! fi

1%,%1 &or&%rii * nii ,!d!,1!"or 1a% &ra&a-!n&!"or in5%-an! ori d!2radan&!.”'ar&.>(* 4ori! ,!r1oana

ar!1&a&a 1a% d!&in%&a * &r!%i! ad%1a d! inda&a inain&!a %n%i #%d!a&or 1a% a a"&%i -a2i1&ra&!

i-,%&!rnii& ,rin "!2! % !

&!r-!n r!/onai" 1a% !"i!ra&a in %r1%" ,ro!d%rii.” 'ar&.'>((* 4ori! ,!r1oana ar! dr!,&%" "a

#%d!ar!a in -od !5i&ai" * in -od ,%"i 1i in&r$%n &!r-!n r!/onai" a a%/!i 1a"! ...” 'ar&. 3'+((.

Privind in&!r/i!r!a on1&i&%irii A1oia9i!i P!r1oan!"or Ui1! d! Po"i9i! 'APUP(

Conv!n&ia ,r!v!d! a: 4ori! ,!r1oana ar! dr!,&%" "a #%d!ar!a in -od !5i&ai" * in -od ,%"i 1i

in&r$%n &!r-!n r!/onai" a a%/!i 1a"! ...” 'ar&. ++'+((* 4Ori! ,!r1oan8* a"! 8r!i dr!,&%ri 7i "i!r&89i

r!%no1%&! d! ,r!/!n&a onv!n9i! a% fo1& 6n8"a&!* ar! dr!,&%" 18 1! adr!1!/! !f!&iv %n!i in1&an9!

na9iona"!* 5iar 7i a&%ni nd 6n8"ar!a 1$ar da&ora %nor ,!r1oan! ar! a% a9iona& 6n !

a&ri%9ii"or "or ofiia"!.”'ar&. +>(.

R!f!ri&or "a in&!r!,&ar!a onvoriri"or &!"!foni! a"! r!"a-an&i"or din ordin%" 1!f%"%i

,o"i&i!i ,oa&! fi invoa& ar&io"%" '+( ar! 2aran&!a/a dr!,&%" ,!r1oan!i "a r!1,!&ar!a vi!9ii 1a"!

,riva&! 7i d! fa-i"i!* a do-ii"i%"%i 18% 7i a or!1,ond!n9!i 1a"!

@. E


6/7

I-,o&riva a%/a&ii"or ad%1! onfor- ar&. '>( 1i ar&.3'+( 1&a&%" 1! ,oa&! a,ara invoand

fa,&%" a D.D. "a -o-!n&%" ar!1&arii !ra 1%1,!& d! vio" dar a fo1& !"i!ra& i-!dia& ! a fo1&

id!n&ifia& ad!vara&%" fa,&%i&or.

I-,o&riva a%/a&ii"or ad%1! onfor- ar&.++'+( 1&a&%" 1! a,ara invoand ar&.++'@( ,rivind„r!1&ran2!r!a "i!r&a&ii d! in&r%nir! 1i d! a1oi!r! ,!n&r% -81%ri n!!1ar!* 6n&r$o 1oi!&a&!

d!-ora&i8* ,!n&r% 1!%ri&a&!a na9iona"8* 1i2%ran9a ,%"i8* a,8rar!a ordinii 7i ,r!v!nir!a

infra9i%ni"or* ,ro&!#ar!a 18n8&89ii 1a% a -ora"!i ori ,!n&r% ,ro&!9ia dr!,&%ri"or 7i "i!r&89i"or

a"&ora.”

I-,o&riva a%/a&i!i d! ina"ar! a ar&io"%"%i ar&.'+( 1&a&%" invoa ar& '@( * ,rin ar!

d!i/ia 1!f%"%i ,o"i&i!i d! a in&!r!,&a &!"!foan!"! r!"a-an&i"or !1&! "!2a"a d!oar!! ,r!vin!

,rod%!r!a d! vio"!n&! ar! ar 1%-ina 1!%ri&a&!a ,%"ia

S&a&%" -ai ,oa&! invoa "a a%/a&ii"! ,rivind ar!1&ar!a 1i d!!1%" "%i D.D. ar&. > din

Conv!n&i! ,o&rivi& ar%ia 4C%r&!a n% ,oa&! fi 1!1i/a&a d!a& d%,a !,%i/ar!a ai"or d! r!%r1

in&!rn!” * iar do1ar%" !1&! r!&ri-i1 or2an!"or d! an5!&8 ,!n&r% o-,"!&ar!a !r!&8ri"or* !" n!fiind

1o"%&iona& 1i n!avand o 5o&arar! #%d!a&or!a1a d!fini&iva.

>.R!f%/%" inr!2i1&rarii a1oia&i! APUP !1&! o a&in2!r! ad%1a dr!,&%"%i "a a1oi!r!

on1ara& in ar&io"%" ++ a" Conv!n9i!i* ,r!%- 1i a dr!,&%"%i d! !


7/7

spete 2008 drepturile omului final

Documents